Incompetence, Stupidity, and Cowardice: the Royal House of Savoy & the Misrule of Italy, 1861-1946, part 2

Part 1Part 2Part 3Part 4Part 5Part 6Part 7Part 8Part 9Part 10Part 11Part 12Part 13Part 14Part 15Part 16Part 17Part 18Part 19Part 20Part 21Part 22Part 23Part 24


The unification of Italy was driven by two forces. The first was the centuries old strategy of the Royal House of Savoy and its supporters to do whatever was necessary to rule more territory. Reading the medieval history of Western Europe, one gets the impression that delegates from the House of Savoy sat in the corner during every treaty negotiation among the great powers and when those powers could not decide which of them should control a certain province, they threw it, like a bone, to the House of Savoy.

Languages of Italy

There was no factual basis upon which a rational person could argue for unification. Hence, the second force was simply the romantic idea of ‘Italy,’ an idea held mainly by the elites. That no such place had ever existed didn’t matter. That there were no such people as ‘Italians’ didn’t matter. That there was no such language as ‘Italian’ did not matter. What we think of as the Italian language is actually Tuscan, the dialect of Tuscany, which was forced on people after unification. The King didn’t even speak it. He spoke Piedmontese. In fact, not many people outside of Tuscany spoke it.

Prior to unification, the various political entities of Italy had been fragmented along lines of economics, language, class, historical rivalries, and intrigue. Unification made this worse especially because the people themselves were not consulted about the idea (which was wise since they probably would have said, “no.”) Economic consolidation created unemployment and as luck would have it, due to overproduction, the wine market collapsed, ruining many. From its very beginning, Italy has been close to what we call today “a failed state.” Point of fact, the whole thing was a bad idea. Making everything more difficult, approximately 80% or more of the ‘new’ Italian people were illiterate.

The country as a whole proved ungovernable, just as many of its constituent pieces, mainly in the South, had proved ungovernable. If the people didn’t want a democratic state then they would get an authoritarian state, which is what happened. The paramilitary carabinieri, created decades before by the House of Savoy, enforced order along with the army, both of these institutions being dominated by loyalists of the Royal House.

[Image courtesy of Wikipedia.]

Published by

Charles McCain

Charles McCain is a Washington DC based freelance journalist and novelist. He is the author of "An Honorable German," a World War Two naval epic. You can read more of his work on his website:

Leave a Reply